Silat vs. Other Martial Arts: A Comparative Analysis

by Mohamad Nizam Mohamed Shapie (GM Prof Dr)

Abstract

In this comparative analysis, we explore the world of Silat, focusing on Pertubuhan Seni Gayung Fatani Malaysia (Seni Gayung Fatani), and assess its position among other prominent martial arts. Established in 1976 by Grandmaster Anuar Abdul Wahab, Seni Gayung Fatani is celebrated for its adaptability, fluidity, and holistic approach to combat training. Contrasted with martial arts like Karate, Taekwondo, Judo, and Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu, Seni Gayung Fatani distinguishes itself with its focus on close-quarters combat, weapon-based techniques, and diverse skill set suitable for various combat scenarios. Beyond its martial applications, Seni Gayung Fatani holds significant cultural and historical importance, serving as a custodian of traditional Silat techniques and promoting cross-cultural understanding. As practitioners engage with Seni Gayung Fatani, they not only acquire valuable self-defence skills but also embark on a journey of personal growth, cultural discovery, and martial mastery, ensuring the continued enrichment and preservation of Silat traditions for future generations.

Introduction:
Silat, an ancient martial art form originating from Southeast Asia, stands as a testament to the region’s rich heritage and cultural diversity. In this comparative analysis, we delve into the world of Silat, with a particular focus on Pertubuhan Seni Gayung Fatani Malaysia (Seni Gayung Fatani), and examine how it stacks up against other well-known martial arts. By exploring the unique characteristics, strengths, and applications of Seni Gayung Fatani (Anuar, 2007; Shapie & Elias, 2015; Shapie et al., 2015;2016) in comparison to other martial arts, we aim to provide insights into the diverse world of combat disciplines.

Overview of Pertubuhan Seni Gayung Fatani Malaysia (PSGFM):
Founded in 1976 by Grandmaster Anuar Abdul Wahab (Nawai et al., 2022), PSGFM is renowned as a leading institution in Malay Silat, promoting its practice globally while staying deeply rooted in Malaysia’s cultural fabric. PSGFM’s philosophy centres around adaptability, fluidity, and mind-body integration, symbolised by Gayung Fatani, which embodies holistic harmony and efficiency in combat. With a comprehensive curriculum and a focus on self-defence and personal development, PSGFM continues to uphold the traditions of Malay martial arts (Shapie, 2002; Ministry of Culture, Art and Tourism, 2002).

Comparison of Silat with Other Martial Arts:
When comparing Seni Gayung Fatani with other martial arts such as Karate, Taekwondo, Judo, and Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu, several distinctions become apparent (Cynarski, 2021). While Karate and Taekwondo emphasise long-range striking techniques, Seni Gayung Fatani focuses on close-quarters combat and utilises weapon-based techniques (Shapie, 2021). Similarly, Judo and Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu emphasise ground fighting and grappling, whereas Seni Gayung Fatani integrates a variety of techniques, including strikes, joint locks, and takedowns, for versatile combat applications (Shapie et al., 2016).

Strengths and Unique Characteristics of Seni Gayung Fatani:
One of Seni Gayung Fatani key strengths lies in its adaptability and versatility. Unlike some martial arts that specialise in specific ranges or techniques, Seni Gayung Fatani equips practitioners with a diverse skill set suitable for various combat scenarios (Shapie, 2021). Furthermore, Seni Gayung Fatani emphasis on situational awareness and real-world self-defence applications sets it apart, providing practitioners with the skills and mindset necessary to navigate potentially dangerous situations effectively (Shapie et al., 2016).

Applications of Seni Gayung Fatani in Self-Defence:
In practical terms, Seni Gayung Fatani techniques excel in self-defence situations due to their effectiveness in close-quarters combat. By focusing on leverage, timing, and control, Seni Gayung Fatani enables practitioners to neutralise threats while minimising harm to themselves and others. Whether facing single or multiple attackers, Seni Gayung Fatani equips individuals with the tools to defend themselves confidently and decisively (Anuar, 2007).

Cultural and Historical Significance of Seni Gayung Fatani:
Beyond its martial applications, Seni Gayung Fatani holds significant cultural and historical importance within the context of Malay martial arts and Southeast Asian heritage. As a custodian of traditional Silat techniques, Seni Gayung Fatani plays a vital role in preserving cultural heritage and promoting cross-cultural understanding (Anuar, 1992). Its philosophy and principles reflect the values of respect, discipline, and community inherent in Malay culture, fostering a sense of identity and belonging among practitioners (Anuar, 2002).

Conclusion:
In conclusion, the comparative analysis of Seni Gayung Fatani against other martial arts highlights its unique strengths, versatility, and cultural significance. Seni Gayung Fatani holistic approach to combat training, combined with its practical self-defence applications and cultural heritage, distinguishes it as a martial art of profound depth and relevance. As practitioners explore the world of Silat through Seni Gayung Fatani, they not only gain valuable self-defence skills but also embark on a journey of personal growth, cultural discovery, and martial mastery. With Seni Gayung Fatani, the ancient art of Silat continues to thrive, enriching lives and preserving traditions for generations to come.

References

Abdul Razak S.N., Muhamad T.A. (2022), Effective Leadership Towards the Star Rating Evaluation of Malaysian Seni Gayung Fatani Malaysia Organization (PSGFM), “Ido Movement for Culture. Journal of Martial Arts Anthropology”, vol. 22, no. 2s, pp. 13-22; doi:10.14589/ido.22.2S.2.

Abdul Razak, S.N., Muhamad T.A., Meng L.K., Abdul Rahim M.R., Mohd Nor M.N., Samsudin H., Nawai N.S. (2022), A Narrative Exploration of Issues in Silat Development From Children To Youth Athletes, “Ido Movement for Culture. Journal of Martial Arts Anthropology”, vol. 22, no. 2s, pp. 23-30; doi: 10.14589/ido.22.2S.3.

Anuar, A.W. (1992). Teknik dalam Seni Silat Melayu (Technique in Malay Silat). Kuala Lumpur: Dewan Bahasa dan Pustaka [in Malay].

Anuar A.W. (2002), Pendidikan dan Nilai-nilai Murni dalam Seni Silat (Education and Noble Values in Martial Arts) [in:] Ministry of Culture, Art and Heritage, Manual jurulatih dan ringkasan mengajar (Instructor manual and summary of coaching), Tahap 1, Seni Silat Malaysia Untuk Jurulatih (First level, Seni Silat Malaysia for coaches), Paperwork, Ministry of Culture, Art and Heritage, Kuala Lumpur [in Malay].

Anuar, A.W. (2007), Silat: The development history of traditional Malay silat and development of modern Silat Malaysia curriculum (Silat: Sejarah perkembangan kurikulum silat Melayu tradisi dan pembentukan kurikulum Silat Malaysia moden), Hizi Print Sdn Bhd, Bandar Baru Bangi, Selangor [in Malay].

Cynarski, W.J. (2021). Lexicon of fighting arts: Masters and their schools. Poland: University of Rzeszow.

Ministry of Culture, Art and Tourism, (2002). Kertas Konsep dan Perlaksanaan; Fasa 1 – Pengembangan Seni Silat Di Sekolah-sekolah (Concept Paper and Enforcement: Phase 1 – Expansion of Seni Silat at Schools). In Manual Jurulatih dan Ringkasan Mengajar, Tahap 1, Seni Silat Malaysia Untuk Jurulatih (Trainers Manual and Summary of Teaching, Level 1, Seni Silat Malaysia For Trainers). Kuala Lumpur.

Nawai, N.S., Shapie, M.N.M., Abdul Rahim M.R, Ramli M.S., Abdul Rahim M.R, Rohaizat N.H., Salman, N.W. (2022), Aminuddin Anuar (1979-Now): The Leadership and Contributions to the Globalization of Malay Silat, [in:] W.J. Cynarski, P. Pawelec, P. Swider, J. Kulasa [eds], 11th IMACSSS International Conference, 5th World Scientific Congress of Combat Sports and Martial Arts, October 13-15, 2022: University of Rzeszow, Poland. Rzeszow, pp. 71-72.

Pawel S., Pawelec P., Reguli Z. Cynarski W.J. (2022), Tourism of Martial Arts Researchers: A Case Study of Participations in An International Congress, Ido Movement for Culture. Journal of Martial Arts Anthropology”, vol. 22, no. 5s, pp. 80-86; doi: 10.14589/ido.22.5.5.

Pawista, J. A., Shapie, M.N.M. (2019). Activity Profile Between Winners and Losers Among Female Exponents in International Silat Olahraga Competition. Revista de Artes Marciales Asiáticas, 14(2s), 25-27.

Pewelec, P., Słopecki, J., Sieber, L. & Rut, P. (2015), Scientific and martial arts’ tourism. The case study of the 3rd IMACSSS International Conference and Congress, “Ido Movement for Culture. Journal of Martial Arts Anthropology”, 15 (1), pp. 46–56.

Shapie, M.N.M. (2021). The Warrior Attitude (Sikap Pendekar) in Malay Silat Encouraging Malaysian Interest in Global Martial Arts and Combat Sports. In “Southeast Asian Martial Arts: A Unique and Complex Cultural Phenomenon,” Ryu, S., Lee, K. & Hwang, J. (eds); p. 26-95. Chungcheongbuk-do, Korea: International Centre of Martial Arts for Youth Development and Engagement under the auspices of UNESCO [ICM]: Chungju-si, Korea.

Shapie, M.N.M. (2022). Teaching Silat for Young Migrants in Malaysia. In “UNESCO ICM – UiTM International Seminar 2022 on Youth Development through Martial Arts,” p. 95-108. Chungcheongbuk-do, Korea: International Centre of Martial Arts for Youth Development and Engagement under the auspices of UNESCO [ICM]: Chungju-si. (ISBN: 9791191300284)

Shapie, M.N.M. and Elias, M.S. (2015). Seni Silat Malaysia: The Malay Arts of Self-Defence. In: Kalina RM (ed.) Proceedings of the 1st World Congress on Health and Martial Arts in Interdisciplinary Approach, HMA 2015, 17–19 September 2015, Czestochowa, Poland; ; 2015. p. 213 Warsaw: Archives of Budo. (ISSN 2450-2650).

Shapie, M.N.M., Oliver, J., O’Donoghue, P. and Tong, R. (2013a). Activity Profile During Action Time in National Silat Competition. Journal of Combat Sports and Martial Arts, 4, 81-86.

Shapie, M.N.M., Oliver, J., O’Donoghue, P.G. and Tong, R. (2013b). Field-based tests of kick and movement speed in martial arts. Journal of Combat Sports and Martial Arts, 2013; 4(2) 131–133.

Shapie, M.N.M., Elias, M.S., Ismail, S. and Hamid, N.A. (2015). Sumbangan Kurikulum Seni Silat Malaysia kepada Warisan dan Tamadun Melayu (Seni Silat Malaysia Curriculum contribution to Heritage and Malay civilization). In “e-Proceedings of the International Conference of Malay Heritage and Civilization (ICOMHAC), 16-17 Disember 2015, Century Helang Hotel, Pulau Langkawi,” Ibrahim S, Salamat ASA., and Zamhury N (eds.); p. 381-404. Langkawi: Universiti Teknologi MARA Cawangan Kedah, Malaysia.

Shapie, M.N.M., Elias, M.S., Anuar, A. (2016). Silat: The Heritage of Malaysia (Silat: Warisan Bangsa Malaysia). The National Department for Culture and Arts, Ministry of Tourism and Culture, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia [in Malay].

Shapie, M.N.M., Jamsari, D.A., Mohd Razi, A., Kusrin, J., Tumijan, W. (2019). Comparison of Action Performances and Outcome Between Winners and Losers in Young Female Silat Tempur Matches. Revista de Artes Marciales Asiáticas, 14(2s), 21-24.

Shapie, M.N.M., Lee, K., Rahim, M.R.M., Vincent P., Nagoor M.A. (2022a), Anuar Abdul Wahab (1945 – 2009): The Leadership and Contributions To The Establishment Of Traditional Art of War Into Modern Malay Silat, [in:] W.J. Cynarski, P. Pawelec, P. Swider, J. Kulasa [eds], 11th IMACSSS International Conference, 5th World Scientific Congress of Combat Sports and Martial Arts, October 13-15, 2022: University of Rzeszow, Poland. Rzeszow, pp. 20-21.

Shapie, M. N.M., Al-Syurgawi, D., Samsudin, H., Nazri, S. M., & Nawai, N. S. (2022b). The Physical Performance Needs in Silat Olahraga: A Coaching Perspective to Establish Plyometric Training in Silat Combat Sport. Jurnal Performa Olahraga, 7(2), 90–97. https://doi.org/10.24036/jpo363019

Disclaimer: This article is Copyright Protected by the Pertubuhan Seni Gayung Fatani Malaysia (PSGFM), Reg. No. PPM-033-10-14032013. Any unauthorized copying will be subject to legal action.